1923investigationcritical
Scientific American Investigation of the Electronic Reactions of Abrams
Albert Abrams' ERA diagnostic system, tested through practicing ERA physicians
Scientific American investigation committee · United States
Method
A year-long committee investigation (reported monthly from October 1923 to September 1924, at a cost of about $20,000) testing ERA practitioners with blinded specimens, including vials of pure single-germ cultures submitted for electronic diagnosis.
Findings
- In the committee's first test, six vials of pure single-disease cultures were each diagnosed as groupings of many diseases — a tube of pneumococcus returned syphilis, tuberculosis, streptococcus, malaria and influenza.
- The committee's final statement: the claims advanced on behalf of the electronic reactions of Abrams and of electronic practice in general are not substantiated and have no basis in fact.
Conclusion
ERA diagnosis judged 'utterly worthless' — 'the height of absurdity'.
The proponent response
The ERA movement and sympathetic press (Pearson's Magazine) dismissed the investigation as orthodox suppression; Abrams died in January 1924, before the final report.